Chanel Ciel de Nuit (Night Sky) vs Jessica Twilight vs Essie Starry Starry Nights

So these three are all supposed to be dupes.  I thought I would do a comparison to show you.  They are all gorgeous and sparkly..... but are they all the same?  I will let you decide.

Bottle pics:

Just the one coat: In the order of the bottles.  Chanel first, then Jessica then Essie.  As you can see the undertones are all quite different. 

 Two coats:  They are evening up a bit - they all look a lot closer.

 Three coats - and they all look pretty much the same now.  Dark and exciting, sparkly.

 Comparison of each fingernail with bottles.

So what do you think?  I think the Chanel is nicest, personally.